Access Education People
Management Information Systems (MIS) Vs HR software for education: An honest review
In today’s world, technology has seamlessly woven itself into every aspect of our lives, and schools are no exception. Education tech is rapidly becoming an essential asset in modern-day institutions, helping them to enhance efficiency, streamline operations and improve the overall educational experience.
Yet, with so many software solutions out there, it can be very difficult to decipher what it is you actually need. And a common query we get asked here at Access Education is,
“What’s the difference between a Management Information System (MIS) and HR software for education?”
So, in this article, we decided to tackle that query head on.
What is MIS in Education?
Management Information Systems (MIS) are comprehensive software and information systems designed to help with data collection, processing, storage and distribution across various educational settings. The main aim of an MIS is to support decision-making at all levels, from operational choices to long-term strategic planning.
Examples of MIS include: Bromcom, Arbor and iSAMS.
The evolution of MIS
In its historical context, Management Information Systems (MIS) primarily served as repositories for pupil data. However, educational institutions soon recognised its potential to also manage staff information.
Over time, many MIS providers observed schools using their software for purposes beyond its initial design, prompting them to incorporate essential (yet basic) HR functionality. Consequently, today, many schools leverage MIS to handle their HR functions.
However, in the rapidly changing landscape of modern education, with teachers leaving at an unprecedented rate, we urge you to consider whether an MIS remains an effective strategy for maintaining Human Resources within your school.
We’ll delve into this further, but for now, let's explore some of the key functions an MIS can offer.
Advantages of MIS in Education
Advantages of MIS in education include:
- Efficiency
- Data-driven decision making
- Improved communication
Limitations of MIS in education
Limitations of MIS in education include:
- Not specialised for HR functions, therefore limited functionality
- Users report that MIS can be clunky and not user friendly
- MIS still requires heavy manual input, leading to errors and a lack of efficiency
Now let’s flip the lid and explore HR software in educational contexts.
What is HR software in education?
Nowadays, HR software is used in almost every industry. However, HR software tailored for the education sector excels in addressing the specific intricacies associated with diverse educational environments, such as maintained schools, independent schools, academies, and Multi-Academy Trusts.
Focusing on the management of human resources-related tasks and data, you can unlock efficiencies around staff management, recruitment, benefits and compliance. What’s more, you can purchase integrated HR and payroll services, ensuring your team remains content and engaged in their roles while receiving accurate and timely compensation.
If you’d like to find out more about HR software in education, check out our latest article - What is HR in schools and how can software help?
Key components of HR software for education
HR software for education typically includes the following features:
- Applicant tracking: Streamlines the hiring process, making it easier for educational institutions to find and onboard qualified staff and faculty.
- Employee onboarding: Simplifies the process of bringing new hires into the institution, including paperwork, training, and orientation.
- Time and attendance tracking: Ensures accurate recording of employee hours, particularly critical for hourly employees and faculty members.
- Payroll processing: Automates payroll calculations and distribution, reducing errors and saving time.
- Performance management: Provides tools for assessing employee performance, setting goals, and conducting evaluations.
- Benefits administration: Helps manage employee benefits, such as healthcare and retirement plans.
- Compliance: Ensures that the institution complies with laws and regulations.
- Employee self-service: Allows your staff to view their own payslips and amend their personal details.
Advantages of HR software in education
The adoption of HR software in education offers several benefits:
- Efficiency
- Accuracy
- Compliance
- Improved faculty and staff management
- Improved staff engagement
- Improved staff retention
- User-friendly software that back-office teams will enjoy using
Limitations of HR software in education
While HR software in education offers numerous advantages, it is essential to carefully consider these benefits in conjunction with potential limitations. For instance:
HR software may not cover the broader scope of MIS, potentially requiring integration with other systems in order to gain more comprehensive data management.
Does not address non HR-related tasks such as finance and budgets.
A more detailed overview of Access Education People
If you’re interested in what our HR software has to offer here at Access Education, watch the video below.
Streamline and centralise your process with HR software for education
MIS Vs HR software for education: A comparison table
| Aspect | MIS (Management Information Systems) | HR (Human Resources) Software |
| Scope | Broad, covers various aspects of educational management, including student information, academic support, and administrative functions. |
Specialised, primarily focuses on HR-related tasks, such as faculty management, recruitment, payroll, performance management, and compliance. |
| Primary Functions |
Manages student records, academic planning, administrative tasks, and offers data analysis for decision-making at all levels. |
Specialised in HR functions, streamlining processes related to faculty and staff, and ensuring compliance with laws and regulations. |
| Advantages |
Comprehensive support for educational functions, data-driven decision-making, enhanced communication, and academic support. |
Efficiency in HR management, accuracy in payroll and benefits administration, compliance with regulations, and improved faculty and staff management. |
| Limitations |
May include features not directly related to HR management, requiring additional HR software for specialised HR functions. |
Focuses on HR, which means it may not address the broader range of administrative tasks or academic support. |
| Use Cases |
Ideal for educational institutions seeking an all-encompassing solution to manage student records, academic support, and administrative tasks. |
Best suited for institutions looking to optimise HR processes, improve faculty and staff management and foster a healthy and happy workplace culture. |
HR Integration and interoperability
In many educational settings, the question isn’t MIS vs HR software but rather how these systems can work together. Integrating MIS and HR software can provide a holistic solution as it leverages the benefits of both systems.
By integrating both, data can flow seamlessly between the systems, resulting in improved efficiency and a more comprehensive overview of your school.
From a high-level perspective, the benefits of integrated MIS and HR software in education are:
- Unified data management
- Streamlined processes
- Comprehensive reporting
- Improved compliance
Bear in mind that successful integration requires a carefully planned and executed project. It will involve collaboration between IT teams, administrators and your software providers.
Cost considerations
The cost is a critical factor when deciding between MIS and HR software. Both solutions have associated costs, and the choice depends on your budget and specific needs. MIS solutions can be more comprehensive, covering a broader range of functions, but they may come with higher initial and ongoing costs.
HR software solutions, on the other hand, are more focused on HR functions and may be more cost-effective. However, you should consider the total cost of ownership, including licensing, implementation, training, and ongoing support.
Factors to consider when evaluating costs include:
- Initial setup costs
- Licensing and subscription fees
- Training and support costs
- Potential costs of integration
- Long-term maintenance costs
The choice between MIS and HR software should align with your budget and the anticipated return on investment, considering both immediate and long-term needs.
Could (and should) you use MIS for HR functions?
There is a fine line between ‘could’ and ‘should’ here. In theory, an MIS can help you achieve certain HR functions. However, bear in mind that these functions are very basic.
The suitability of MIS for your HR needs depends on your definition of HR within your educational setting. If your HR activities primarily revolve around basic staff file management, an MIS may suffice. But, if your goal is to genuinely enhance your workforce and cultivate a positive workplace culture, opting for an education-specific HR solution is highly advisable.
Final thoughts
The decision between MIS and HR software for education is a significant one. It requires careful consideration of your setting’s unique needs, goals and budget, whether you are a single school, academy or part of an MAT.
Both MIS and HR software bring distinct advantages. However, the true power may lie in the synergy between the two solutions, through integration.
Enhance staff engagement and retention with Access Education People
